Grand Moff Tim
Some call me... Tim
Screw the show, I need a new novel :c
This site may earn a commission from merchant links like Ebay, Amazon, and others.
Meh, I felt like they should have done a bit more with this being the season opener...Just seemed, well, slow for some reason; at least moreso than it should have. And any word for sure that this book is getting split in two or not? I haven't bothered to really look into it.
The Davos and Stannis was exchange brilliant. They could have added a bit more suspense to Davos being alive dragging his scene on the rock out a minute or two longer.
Charles Dance was amazing. He is going to be incredible this season. I love how they put in his final line from one of Tyrion's POV chapters.
The scenes beyond the wall were terrible imo. They deviated to far from the book for no real reason. What is up with Tormund? He is one of the funniest characters in the book. He didn't even say "HUR HUR!". I understand they have a very limited budget but a bit of fighting at the fist would have been cool.
Astapor looks great! They only shied away from a few of the nasty Unsullied details. I will be epic to see this plot come to the big screen.
mod edit: spoiler tags, use some[\QUOTE]
Okay, first of all, for your second paragraph, please use spoiler tags. Upcoming major plot point, and all.
I don't understand how it's any more a spoiler than ANYTHING else posted here in regular typeface.
A) None of the involved characters have really been fleshed out in any detail yet, so those only watching the show will have no idea who's wedding it is. They're free to speculate, but being that I didn't say "these people die," I don't see why it should be marked as a spoiler.
B) "Red Wedding" means nothing unless you've read the books, in which case it's not a spoiler. I may as well have said something about the "green goblin;" would've had about the same amount of plot revealed in and of itself.
If people wanted to look it up, that's not my problem as they could simply go read the wiki for the series right now and figure out what I mean. It seems counterproductive to use the spoilers for every mundane thing mentioned....hell even your last paragraph doesn't reveal anything that those watching the show wouldn't know already, thus making it moot to green it out.
I don't understand how it's any more a spoiler than ANYTHING else posted here in regular typeface.
It's really not that big deal, no need to start one of your arguments in this thread as well![]()
I'd say that they were the low point, although they weren't bad per se, because it can never be bad when Rose Leslie is on screen.
I will admit, the scene with the wight trying to kill Sam wasn't as exciting as it should have been, and that whole scene felt anti-climactic because of how they'd managed to end Season 2 with the whole army of undead.
The fact is though, those battle scenes are super expensive, especially when you get all the CGI involved, which would be a necessity here because the Others are 100% CGI.
I did like how they kept in the bits about the slave trader insulting Danny in Ghiscari because he knew that she couldn't understand, good fun.
Dance of Dragons Spoilers
I'm going to be so pissed if Jon is really dead. And I'm bummed with how little Bran was in the story.
I'm pretty sure he isn't.
My theory is, that (I'm not at my desk currently, so I'll have to make it short) - Jon vargs into Ghost, will be brought back by Mellisandre, is AA reborn.
I'm thinking you're right.
There a lot of evidence to support it. The wounds smoking thing,and Melisandre only seeing Jon when she is looking for Stannis.
I still think that he is the son of Rhaegar and Lyanna.
I think he definitely is, and that just satisfies some of the conditions of whatever prophecies surround AA.
if he comes back though, doesn't he have to sacrifice someone to make his sword? who might he have left to him that could fill that for him, since Ygritte is already dead and I don't think he moved on to anyone else.
I'm thinking you're right.
More book 5 spoilers
There a lot of evidence to support it. The wounds smoking thing,and Melisandre only seeing Jon when she is looking for Stannis.
I still think that he is the son of Rhaegar and Lyanna.