Was just looking at one of these yesterday (in person) thinking, man, crazy that this is ~$9k, and then right next to it are all the murphy aged historics, some with pretty blah tops, also in that same range. I mean, it did look pretty great, but I guess if buying a high end Gibson, the demographic is for more traditional tastes.
That's probably my one big gripe with the Murphy stuff, they don't choose the best tops. I get that it's more about fitting the specs of the old guitars, but some of those had knockout tops too.
Though the best they did was a number of years back. They did runs of "odd" tops. Stuff like reverse grain and one-piece. That looked really cool aged.