So some 1000 grit sandpaper and about two hours of hand sanding worked out pretty well.
Here were the original tuners:
View attachment 147444
Here’s 3 I had done with one tuner untouched:
View attachment 147445
Here’s the new tuners with the rest of the hardware:
View attachment 147446
And done:
View attachment 147447
Good enough for me.
The relic'ing just looks right on this LP. I really like it. Nice!