mindwalker
Well-Known Member
Been trying Reaper here as well but since I'm using a Mac I might give Logic a spin very soon (in some Apple Store) to see how well it integrates with the OS. I find Reaper to be quite powerful but many times I find myself having to look it up on the Internet how to do something simple
for example just yesterday I was trying to record a simple MIDI loop starting with a kick and snare and then I wanted to do a second dub to add a hi-hat but it was adding a new take and then I didn't seem to be able to merge the two. I'm sure there's ways to do this but again.. it's just an example of how sometimes I wish it would be simpler. The menus and options are really so exhaustive that many of them you don't even understand what they mean. I also couldn't get the pinch to zoom to work on the MIDI editor although I've changed the corresponding action on the actions list to act to MultiZoom but well...
And that reminds me.. before you try to use Reaper on OSX you really should change the default horizontal / vertical scroll actions to the trackpad swipe gestures otherwise as soon as you try to swipe vertically on the track view you end up zooming in... which is fine for many but after you get used to OSX is really not what you expect (and the same for the horizontall scrolling not being inverted by default.. something that can be changed too on the Actions though)
But for tracking guitars it's really easy.. although I find take comping still more intuitive in Logic from what I've seen in videos. With Reaper you still have to split the takes and then manually pick these building blocks from each take to make it your final cut.
But yeah Logic is a much bigger beast and can hog the system down I would imagine.. although I've ran GarageBand and Reaper and for both MIDI work and Guitar Amp modelling with monitoring they seem to be on par in CPU and memory usage (GarageBand is supposed to run on the same engine as Logic so I guess Logic will have a similar foot print)
But Reaper is so customizable.. that's undeniable! But I personally don't want to customize too much.. I just want to use the darn thing
I tried a couple of themes for Reaper but I always end up going to the Default one... the icons aren't pretty but the rest is all there and fully functional (I found themes sometimes to remove vital buttons such as the monitor button from the track lane ?)
for example just yesterday I was trying to record a simple MIDI loop starting with a kick and snare and then I wanted to do a second dub to add a hi-hat but it was adding a new take and then I didn't seem to be able to merge the two. I'm sure there's ways to do this but again.. it's just an example of how sometimes I wish it would be simpler. The menus and options are really so exhaustive that many of them you don't even understand what they mean. I also couldn't get the pinch to zoom to work on the MIDI editor although I've changed the corresponding action on the actions list to act to MultiZoom but well...
And that reminds me.. before you try to use Reaper on OSX you really should change the default horizontal / vertical scroll actions to the trackpad swipe gestures otherwise as soon as you try to swipe vertically on the track view you end up zooming in... which is fine for many but after you get used to OSX is really not what you expect (and the same for the horizontall scrolling not being inverted by default.. something that can be changed too on the Actions though)
But for tracking guitars it's really easy.. although I find take comping still more intuitive in Logic from what I've seen in videos. With Reaper you still have to split the takes and then manually pick these building blocks from each take to make it your final cut.
But yeah Logic is a much bigger beast and can hog the system down I would imagine.. although I've ran GarageBand and Reaper and for both MIDI work and Guitar Amp modelling with monitoring they seem to be on par in CPU and memory usage (GarageBand is supposed to run on the same engine as Logic so I guess Logic will have a similar foot print)
But Reaper is so customizable.. that's undeniable! But I personally don't want to customize too much.. I just want to use the darn thing